By Harrisburg Senior Advisor Care Team · October 8, 2026
Of the 68 rated nursing homes in the four counties, 32 hold four or five stars and 28 hold one or two (CMS, October 1, 2026). Staffing and turnover vary more within each county than between counties.
The county-by-county picture
Each figure below comes straight from CMS's Provider Data Catalog as of October 1, 2026. Staffing is reported nurse staffing hours per resident per day; turnover is the share of nursing staff who left over a year.
| County | Certified homes | Four or five stars | One or two stars | Median nurse hours / resident / day | Median nursing turnover |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dauphin County | 8 | 1 | 5 | 3.55 | 51.9% |
| Cumberland County | 17 | 8 | 6 | 3.66 | 45.0% |
| Lancaster County | 31 | 19 | 10 | 4.32 | 41.7% |
| York County | 12 | 4 | 7 | 3.52 | 45.3% |
Lancaster County has by far the most nursing homes, many of them inside continuing care campuses. Dauphin has the fewest, with several large homes in and around Harrisburg.
What a star rating measures
CMS builds the overall rating from three pieces: health inspection results over recent survey cycles, staffing hours reported through payroll records, and quality measures such as falls, pressure ulcers and returns to the hospital. Stars are relative to other homes in the same state, so a three-star Pennsylvania home sits near the middle of Pennsylvania homes.
A serious recent deficiency can cap a home's rating, and a home that changes owners may see its numbers shift quickly. That is why the date on the rating matters.
Why staffing and turnover deserve a closer look
Pennsylvania has required at least 3.2 hours of direct care per resident per day since July 2024. Reported hours above that floor help, but turnover may say more about daily life on a hall. A home that replaces half its nursing staff each year struggles to keep residents' routines, preferences and warning signs in anyone's memory.
Ask any home you are considering how long its charge nurses and aides have worked there, and whether it uses agency staff on nights and weekends.
Campus homes and stand-alone homes
Homes inside continuing care campuses often give their own residents priority for beds, and some admit few outside residents to long-term care. Stand-alone homes, including several large ones in Harrisburg, Lancaster and York, handle much of the region's short-term rehab after hospital discharges. Both kinds appear in our roster with CMS's flag showing which is which.
Short-stay versus long-stay quality
CMS splits its quality measures into short-stay and long-stay sets. Short-stay measures, such as how often rehab patients improve in mobility or return to the hospital, matter most when a parent is heading to rehab after surgery or illness. Long-stay measures, such as falls with major injury, pressure ulcers and use of antipsychotic medication, matter most when a parent will live in the home. A home can score well on one set and poorly on the other.
Each nursing home page in our roster shows both ratings where CMS publishes them. Read the one that fits your situation rather than relying on the overall star alone.
Fines, payment denials and the abuse icon
CMS also publishes federal fines and payment denials over the last three years, and it marks homes cited for abuse with an icon on Care Compare. A fine signals that surveyors found a problem serious enough to penalize; a pattern of fines across years is a stronger signal than a single one. Our pages show the count and total for each home, alongside the latest inspection date and deficiency count.
Ask any home with recent fines what was found and what changed. Administrators who can describe the corrective steps specifically are usually the ones who made them.
Visiting with the numbers in hand
Bring the CMS figures on your tour. If staffing hours are below the county median, ask how many aides work the hall your parent would live on during evenings and weekends. If turnover is high, ask how long the director of nursing has been in the job. If the latest survey cited infection control, ask what training followed. The answers turn a list of numbers into a picture of the place.
Where to find the inspection itself
Each nursing home's Care Compare record links to its full inspection reports, which describe what surveyors saw and the scope and severity of each deficiency. Reading one report end to end takes twenty minutes and often explains a rating better than any summary.
A note on new owners
CMS flags homes whose ownership changed in the last year. New owners can bring investment and fresh management or cost-cutting and turnover. Ask any recently sold home what has changed for staff and residents since the sale.
Using the numbers well
Use the ratings to trim a long list to three or four homes. Then read each home's most recent inspection in full, visit the hall where your parent would live, and talk with residents and families. Numbers point you toward questions; they do not answer them.
Frequently asked questions
Are CMS ratings reliable?
They are the best public comparison available, built from inspections, staffing data and quality measures, but they lag reality and should be paired with a visit.
Who inspects nursing homes?
The Pennsylvania Department of Health, on behalf of CMS.
Does a five-star home take Medical Assistance?
Many do, but not all for every bed; ask admissions directly.
Where are the figures for each home?
On each home's page in our nursing home roster.