Free senior care help for families across the Harrisburg, Lancaster and York area, at no cost to you.
Call (717) 895-9578
Harrisburg Senior Advisor(717) 895-9578

Assisted living or a secured dementia unit?

The question is not the diagnosis but the risk: wandering, exit-seeking and the need for constant redirection.

Quick answer

Often, in the early stages: a personal care home or assisted living residence can care for a resident with memory loss who does not try to leave and can follow the daily routine with reminders, but it may not lock the doors without a licensed secured unit.

Home›Comparisons›Assisted living or a secured dementia unit?

Can someone with dementia live on an ordinary assisted living floor?

Often, in the early stages: a personal care home or assisted living residence can care for a resident with memory loss who does not try to leave and can follow the daily routine with reminders, but it may not lock the doors without a licensed secured unit.

Signs that the ordinary floor is no longer enough include walking out of the building, getting lost on the way back from meals, agitation late in the day and needing someone nearby most of the time. The home's assessment should flag these changes.

What does a secured dementia unit add?

Locked or alarmed exits, secured outdoor space, a written preadmission screening, quarterly plan reviews and staff with six extra hours of dementia training a year, all under 55 Pa. Code 2600.231 to 2600.239.

50 of the region's 127 licensed homes carry a secured dementia care unit or special care unit on their DHS certificate, 1,777 unit places in all (7 in Dauphin, 11 in Cumberland, 19 in Lancaster, 13 in York County); the largest unit, 92 places, is at Country Meadows of West Shore in Mechanicsburg. Units range from a dozen places inside a larger home to buildings where nearly every resident lives behind the secured doors.

How does the cost change?

No published survey gives a memory care median for Pennsylvania; units usually charge more than the same home's regular floor, through a higher base rate or care-level fees, so ask each home for both prices side by side.

Medical Assistance does not pay a personal care home's dementia unit. If money is likely to run out, ask early whether the home's campus includes a nursing home that accepts Medical Assistance, since some families plan the eventual move that way.

Is a nursing home ever better for dementia?

Yes, when the person also needs skilled nursing, is bed-bound, has difficulty swallowing or has behaviors the unit cannot manage safely; nursing homes care for many residents with dementia under their Department of Health license.

Some nursing homes in the region run dedicated dementia neighborhoods. Their CMS pages show staffing and inspection results, which a personal care home unit does not publish.

What should we ask when touring a unit?

Ask how many staff work the unit on each shift including overnight, how long the team has worked there, how residents spend an ordinary afternoon, and what would lead the home to say it can no longer care for your parent.

Also ask to see the unit's outdoor space and the last inspection summary. Visiting at mealtime shows more than a scheduled tour does.

Side by side

Ordinary floorSecured dementia unit
DoorsMust stay unlockedLocked or alarmed lawfully
AdmissionStandard screeningDementia diagnosis plus written cognitive screening
Training12 hours a year for direct care staff18 hours a year including 6 on dementia
Plan reviewsYearly or on a change in conditionAt least every three months

Based on 55 Pa. Code Chapters 20, 2600 and 2800, publications of the Pennsylvania Departments of Human Services, Health and Aging, and the CMS, VA and CareScout tables named on this page. Our editorial standards explain how sources are chosen.

Not sure where to start?

Answer five questions and a local advisor will come back with senior care options in Dauphin, Cumberland, Lancaster and York counties that fit your situation and budget. It is free, and there is no obligation.

Find care options
Find Facilities Near You